“Karachi Beach girls” running around “Lombard Trees” looking for “work permit for their spouses” November 28, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in numbers-in-my-life, weird.3 comments
To answer therandomizer’s questions.
So … tell me ! What search queries have brought people to your site? What is the most consistent topic? Where do you get most of your traffic from? And what is the weirdest query someone has entered to find your site?
![]()
Here is the list for today:
eeyore
karachi beach girls
Nasim Talib Black Swan
nris work permit for spouse
orkut friend request specials
“sagarika ghose”
book ends
lombard trees
greetings to teacher leaving for higher
profound sentences
Think about the guy who is looking for the work permit for his spouse and finds this post.
Beach girls ? On this blog which someone said ” ruminates on everything but sex” ?
And lombard trees ? What are they ?
Well, what do I say except that this is what Einstein thought of Gandhi :
Generations to come, it may be, will scarce believe that such one as this ever in flesh and blood walked upon this earth.
So lets paraphrase Einstein and say that “generations to come, it may be, will scarce believe that such humans as using keyword-based search engines ever in flesh and blood walked upon this earth.
Darwin award, Child labor and Sweatshops November 28, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in economics, history, weird.add a comment
Meet Toni Vernelli:
Incredibly, so determined was she that the terrible “mistake” of pregnancy should never happen again, that she begged the doctor who performed the abortion to sterilise her at the same time. He refused, but Toni – who works for an environmental charity – “relentlessly hunted down a doctor who would perform the irreversible surgery.
And why ?
Every person who is born uses more food, more water, more land, more fossil fuels, more trees and produces more rubbish, more pollution, more greenhouse gases, and adds to the problem of over-population.”
Linked from here. One of the comments on the post implies that she should next be aiming for the Darwin award.
~~~
The sweatshop dilemma – this time in the Indian context – manhole covers headed for New York City made in India. Dani discusses discusses the implications of this article as a starting point. But we know that the debate is more general. A related article by Amit Varma on Child Labor is here. Usha has a few very interesting accounts and personal recollections pertaining to the dilemma.
Then there is Nicolas Kristof’s very controversial sweatshops column in the Times.
And Krugman’s article from 2001 where he said :
There is an old European saying: anyone who is not a socialist before he is 30 has no heart; anyone who is still a socialist after he is 30 has no head. Suitably updated, this applies perfectly to the movement against globalization — the movement that made its big splash in Seattle back in 1999 and is doing its best to disrupt the Summit of the Americas in Quebec City this weekend.
The facts of globalization are not always pretty. If you buy a product made in a third-world country, it was produced by workers who are paid incredibly little by Western standards and probably work under awful conditions. Anyone who is not bothered by those facts, at least some of the time, has no heart.
But that doesn’t mean the demonstrators are right. On the contrary: anyone who thinks that the answer to world poverty is simple outrage against global trade has no head — or chooses not to use it. The anti-globalization movement already has a remarkable track record of hurting the very people and causes it claims to champion.
And thats enough material for a high-school debate on sweatshops. Of course, you will then be below 30 and with much of the above material open to criticism of having no heart.
Funny links November 26, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in humor.8 comments
Limericks: I have always loved them. Check out links from here. Aparna blogs newsmericks here.
~~~
Bumper stickers: There is Anti-Bush, there is pro-Bush (which other country makes so much fun of their heads of state in general ? ). There is pro-environment and anti. They are all funny, but there was at least one I did not understand.
What can bald people do to promote global warming (that others can’t) – something about reflecting heat and light back rather than absorb ?
~~~
Joy: Has gotten into the habit of having weird ‘Desi guys’ * returning back * to stalk her online.
Not so funny actually.
A non-travelogue November 26, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in humor.add a comment
The Bible apparently says
Treat Others As You Would Like To Be Treated.
George Bernard Shaw however differs :
Do not do unto others as you would expect they should do unto you. Their tastes may not be the same.
I am back from this really amazing trip and would imagine wanting to blog about it. But I don’t take to travelogues too well, they bore me. Now, although Bernard Shaw thinks I should blog about the trip anyway, the Bible suggests I should not.
Well, I agree with many things from Shaw,
and maybe none from the Bible,
so I will go with the Bible for now
and spare you the travelogue.
["gue" is silent to maintain the rhyme scheme]
My previous attempt at putting down a travel account was better, although previous attempts at verses (such as above) were admittedly worse.
Sample something from Shaw here.
When ? November 21, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in contemplation.5 comments
In conversation with a friend I have known for 20 years asking him to give his take on turning 26. Lets turn over the mike to him.
Its hard to believe that I am 26. There was a time when people would talk about “today’s kids” and they would mean us. Its not us any more.
When was the first time you used the phrase “Current generation” to refer to another group ? Kids People of what approximate age would you consider to be of your generation ? How old should a person be so you can use the phrase “current generation” and he/she won’t think its him/her ? When did you first think that you should not desist from engaging in certain activities because life is too short and life in a healthy body that can take strenuous shocks is even shorter ? When did it first occur to you (if it did) as to what kind of a place your grand kids would grow up and how much technology would have changed things by then ? Rather among the many future developments that you anticipate, which do you think will not happen in your lifetime ?
No you don’t have to be the brooding Eeyore when it comes to the above thoughts. I am talking about the first time many of these thoughts you actually felt – not read, not heard, not spoken to – but felt personally.
Whats not in the source code ? November 20, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in humor, india, science.add a comment
Look at this piece of news.
The exploration of the human genome has long been relegated to elite scientists in research laboratories. But that is about to change. An infant industry is capitalizing on the plunging cost of genetic testing technology to offer any individual unprecedented — and unmediated — entree to their own DNA.
For as little as $1,000 and a saliva sample, customers will be able to learn what is known so far about how the billions of bits in their biological code shape who they are. Three companies have already announced plans to market such services, one yesterday.
Great ! The next time someone wants to know why I started balding at 19 and am all but done with it at 26, ( “Was it the swimming pool water”, “May be KREC hostel water”, “I am sure it was the Boston Winter”), I might be able to give them an entire subsequence of A, T, G, C for an explanation. (Geneticists out there – does this make sense ?)
Jokes apart, this is precious stuff. Sure, the science is at still at the early stages and so is the technology – I reckon within 2 years the costs of the above indulgence may come down by 20-30%. And I am going to go get it ! What kind of stuff do you find there anyway ?
Like other testers of 23andMe’s service, my first impulse was to look up the bits of genetic code associated with the diseases that scare me the most.
But in the bar charts that showed good genes in green and bad ones in red, I found a perverse sense of accomplishment. My risk of breast cancer was no higher than average, as was my chance of developing Alzheimer’s. I was 23 percent less likely to get Type 2 diabetes than most people. And my chance of being paralyzed by multiple sclerosis, almost nil. I was three times more likely than the average person to get Crohn’s disease, but my odds were still less than one in a hundred.
Seriousness apart (!), the great practitioners of the system of arranged marriages will keep up with the times in a rather queer manner – I presume we in India will soon start circulating and matching DNA substrings instead of the horoscopes for prospective alliances causing a recession in the astrology market.
Of course, astrologers may well be able to predict this recession and take corrective steps.
Superachievers – Attention parents !! November 20, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in education.6 comments
The 2008 Rhodes Scholars announced. Look through these profiles of these superachievers to get a picture of just how high the standards are.
I could not quite find too similar a list for the Indian scholars though. This is the best I could. (2007 winners)
Some more tidbits here.
She has a perfect academic record at MIT — A’s in all her courses, including linguistics and fiction reading — and plans to study immunology. Of course, she’s practically an expert already, having worked in six laboratories and designed a device that isolates white blood cells to better understand how the human body reacts to injury.
Thats Melis Anahtar at 21.
This section of Cecil Rhodes’ will is telling indeed.
My desire being that the students who shall be elected to the Scholarships shall not be merely bookworms I direct that in the election of a scholarship regard shall be had to (i) his literary and scholastic attainments (ii) his fondness of and success in manly outdoor sports such as cricket football and the like (iii) his qualities of manhood truth courage devotion to duty sympathy for and protection of the weak kindliness unselfishness and fellowship and (iv) his exhibition during school days of moral force of character and of instincts to lead and to take an interest in his school-mates for those latter attributes will be likely in afterlife to guide him to esteem the performance of public duties as his highest aim.
For the forever nitpicking, forever aggrieved ones, don’t fret, for here is what you were expecting
The words ‘manhood’ and ‘manly’ were removed when the law was changed to throw open the scholarships to both sexes.
Actually, I would interested in reading their parents’ profiles as well. Seriously, nothing sarcastic about it. I think parents have a big role to play here because this scholarship is not just about being brilliant or even a genius – its about doing lots of very different things and doing them well. I would think it is a totally different kind of achievement and wager that its also a rather poor predictor of Nobel Laureates (the hard sciences), Field Medalists (‘The Math Nobel’) and Turing Award winners (‘ The Computer Science Nobel’).
Assorted links November 20, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in blogging, economics, life, technology.add a comment
Okay, so if you could read say 15 blogs, which should you read to be most up to date ? (No ! not this one
)
Being among the first to pick up on Internet news and gossip and rapidly detecting contamination anywhere in a water supply system are similar problems, at least from a computer scientist’s point of view. Both can be solved with a versatile algorithm developed by Carnegie Mellon University researchers.
Check the website for more details and their list here.
~~~
Questions that people ask economists these days. The answers they get are more impressive (to me) than they get from other Agony-aunt columnists. Except I don’t know Gloria finds them as impressive or useful.
More in the same series is Tyler’s incredible exposition of ideas on when to utter the “I love you” phrase. I hope this inspires a new round of Ballywood dialogs and lyrics.
~~~
Tyler Cowen’s “The cost of the Iraq war.” For which as Cowen says “….I’ve received more email about it than any other article I wrote this year and the paper edition isn’t even out yet.”
Zen and the art of bicycle maintenance November 18, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in contemplation, life, reminisces-1990s.2 comments
For the last 2 weeks my bicycle tires deflated on their own (volition??) and that made for depressing days
. The front tire would deflate in about 18 hours and the back in 3-4 hours. The simple solution would be to just replace the tubes for a not-at-all princely sum of $16 for 2 tubes. Or else you can buy yourself a patch kit – a little box with glue, patches and sandpaper and then patch the tube by yourself. What did I do ? Surprisingly this time I turned to the latter option.
And there is a reason I choose the word ’surprisingly’. Over the years things have turned out such that given a choice between working with my hands versus the mind, would prefer the latter (exception being my love of cooking (an earlier konfession). It was not always like this – my free time as a young teenager was spent in the garden digging pits, watering plants, climbing coconut trees, painting something (not art, maybe furniture, walls etc.) or cleaning something else.
This was until about 1996. Starting class XI (1997) though I got busy with books and learning – of all kinds , including of course academic. Most of my vacations were spent doing something to further career interests and general curiosity. If they weren’t spent on the IISc campus, they were spent in the MIT (Manipal) library catching up with (what were then) obscure periodicals like the HBR, IEEE Spectrum , Potentials etc. If one of those (vacations) was indeed spent partly at my native place, it was spent either online or at an old public library (where I first laid my hands on this disgusting book).
The long term optimization was heavily geared towards saving time, being efficient and quickly washing my hands off anything that uuh… required washing hands ! Lazy weekend meant lazily lying on the bed with the laptop. Anything physical that is broken would lay broken until it became life threatening and anything digital/virtual that were broken would be fixed as if it were (life threatening) when it almost never was. Reality became little more than a really really good simulation and the comfort of algorithmic certainty was too much to let go of in favor of something more nuanced that life’s realities tend to be.
Today 10 years after that phase of life began and after completing what might turn out to be all of my formal education, life seems to have come a full circle ellipsoid ! There is an incredible urge to open up those old cupboards of life-skills, hone them just a little bit and get my hands dirty.
So I sat down on the kitchen floor and before me was the ‘ungainly’ sight of my cycle on the floor (not this bad !), the tubes ripped out of the tire as if it were an accident spot. With some effort that involved dipping the tubes in water to see where the leak is, finding it, gluing in a patch, rediscovering practical physics 101 on the way and then putting it all back, blowing air into the tubes and leaving my cycle overnight (to recuperate (!)) to make sure its all okay. And it was !!
When drunk poets wrote about experiencing the joy of little things in life, it wasn’t the alcohol.
To live for November 18, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in music.1 comment so far
This piece.
To play this one day. Blindfolded.
Why do people stop blogging ? November 17, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in blogging, contemplation.7 comments
Update appended at the end of article
Who is the most famous blogger you know who stopped blogging ? Or lets say who among frequent bloggers do you know of that stopped blogging ? Why ? Why do people stop blogging ? And I am not talking about bloggers who blogged infrequently and indifferently in the first place, not those who have one ‘bad day at work’ and none to come home rant about it. My question is about regular bloggers who seemed like they will go on and on. Maybe the phenomenon of blogging has not seen cycles and recessions (!!), so its hard to find bloggers who cease to blog. I don’t know.
I am trying to understand the place and role of blogging in a blogger’s life. Its not like tennis players who stop playing – surely you can play only that long. But blogging does not require physical activity. Its not even about say violinists – playing a music instrument is special skill and very few do that in the first place and few give up. Its not even a full-time job for most that you retire from one day.
I think blogging is somewhere in between – it requires some skill, but once that is out of the way and once you have a dedicated (even if small) readership, what you need to keep blogging is time and sense of lack of indifference about the world around you. Or Ben puts it :
When someone maintains a blog, it usually means their mind is cranking so quickly that they need one more outlet through which to channel that energy and express their thoughts. It usually means they’re engaged with the world and what’s happening. It usually means they like to write and believe in the idea-generation that comes from writing well. Yes, it probably means they’re a little self-involved and self-important, but I prefer that to someone who lacks self-confidence. In other words, I like people who have a “posture” in the world.
What other real world activity does blogging compare to ? Reading ? Probably, but if you get busy for a couple of months and stop reading, you can still get back to it. With blogging it might be harder.
Is blogging like friendship in some ways ? Lots of friendships are disrupted just because you were too busy to call/meet for a few months and then you don’t know where to start. They are also disrupted when you get married, have children and suddenly have limited time. In general, for any number of reasons and events in life that suddenly demand a diversion of commitment of time and energy friendships may be disrupted. And blogging too.
And several years after you have stopped blogging you may come back to read your blog and think about the times you wrote those posts, how aroused you were about the world around you, how naive and self-important your thoughts were and how there seemed to be no end in sight. Just like old friendships.
Why do people stop blogging ?
Update: Another reason to wonder why people stop blogging. (NSFW)
War and South India November 17, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in history, india.add a comment
Another excellent article by Rama Guha :
Malavalli has been untouched by war for the past 200 years; so, in fact, has the whole of South India. This fact needs to be more carefully pondered by professional historians as well as by ordinary citizens. For, of which other part of India, or indeed of the world, could one say that two centuries have passed since the cannons boomed and the tanks roared? In this respect we South Indians have been very fortunate indeed.
This is not a novel thought certainly – maybe Guha himself must have said it before. I remember reading something along these lines a few years ago in one of Naipaul’s essays. Naipaul’s writings of India don’t have too great a reputation, but could someone have got everything wrong ?
(especially if Naipaul and Guha agree on something
).
I wanted to mention this while the North-South debate came up briefly – that the north has repeatedly borne the brunt of violence in the Indian sub-continent , especially external aggressions. But the relative disorder, the relatively large impoverished masses, the caste complexities, the relatively eroded human capital over decades – this is the price that part of India has had top pay. Not altruism but in self-defence one might argue, but I think this has been some sort of a positive externality for the South. This is not of course to defend any racial discrimination either way, but an acknowledgment that there are a few fundamental differences between South and parts of the North. Not all of these differences matter all the time, but some of them matter some of the time.
Whats there in Bangalore November 17, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in culture, india.1 comment so far
As MINT launches in Bangalore, it appears they have timed it well to have a special feature on “Why we love Bangalore” (other than that it makes business sense
). That page there, with famous Bangaloreans singing paeans of Bangalore City.
All that is fine until someone asks you “what is there in Bangalore to see ?” Or to make it sound even worse, what is there in Bangalore for someone who has seen every other Indian city ? Maybe its an unfair question – for a city is more than its monuments, museums and galleries. Yet it only means that Bangalore does not have something to offer to everybody.
I would take someone to the IISc campus – it comes with an attached botanical garden, a bookstore, a coffee shop for some obesity inducing vada sambhar where if you are lucky, you may occasionally catch an eccentric researcher talking to his tea cup. (And if you are not so lucky, a tree may fall on you as you take in the samosa at teaboard.) But then not all friends would appreciate this (would any??) – so maybe it will be Vidhan Souda and Lal Bagh.
City notes and Ben’s blog November 15, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in America, blogging, culture, people.7 comments
Cities have personalities sure. Here is about Los Angeles. Here about San Francisco (10 reasons why someone hates it !)
I spent barely a few hours there ( LA ) and I did not really take to the place too well – it was like one big warehouse/shop floor. Or maybe I saw all the wrong places. Now I think I just want to go there once, check out the landmarks and be done with it !
On a related note, you kind of get tired of people talking of how the city they grew up was unique and the best place ever. Yes, the best it was, for them. Rest could not care less. Topics to avoid in conversation arguments with Mumbaikars – Mumbai, Madras-ites – Madras, so on and so forth.
I linked to the articles above from Ben Casnocha’s blog. Ben is “an entrepreneur, writer, and college student currently based in Los Angeles county. I’m 19 years old.” Do sample from his list of what he thinks are his best writings. Incredible range and depth for someone that young.
CMU roundup November 15, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in CMU.add a comment
CMU awards an honorary doctorate to President Kalam.
CMU Tartan racing team wins the DARPA Urban Challenge !! Read more about the challenge here. Believe me, this is not what you think – cheering just another some college sports team.
In much older news, watch this short video of the Robocup.
If you could not catch the longer version of Prof. Randy Pausch’s lecture here, then maybe a shorter one when Randy appeared on Oprah’s show. You really must, please do.
Economics everywhere. More than. November 15, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in economics, humor, image.add a comment
Greg Mankiw points to this really cool advertisement.
I am feeling really wicked today. Therefore, in the interest of promoting humor via economics and of not being economical in promoting humor, here is what I did to the image.
Original link for the image.
Links assorted November 14, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in assorted.4 comments
Blogger loses another blogger. This time it is Vishnu who went left Blogger to hang out on wordpress. Last time it was therandomizer. And prior to that was myself, I moved in February 2007. Somewhere in between DK gave up.
Except, one of the drawbacks of wordpress vis-a-vis blogger (for potential immigrants (into WordPress I mean
)..anyone going the other way ?? ) is that you can’t customize the layout if you have the free account.
By the way, you really must read Vishnu’s sentiments on Diwali away from home.
Aloofness and freedom from all the complexities of these relations or struggle to be with like minded people? Or to reform myself drastically to be in sync with people around me? As I toyed with all these ideas the mexican waiter of the Indian Restaurant came over and handed me the bill. I wished the the elderly Indian employee of the restaurant (who appeared to me to be of my father’s age) , who showed me to my table was in his place so that I could atleast wish him Happy Ganesh Chaturdhi. I waited two more minutes to see if he would come by, but the mexican still persisted “Is there anything I can do for your sir?” I had to mumble a thanks and wish him a good evening and return back all alone…
~~~
Cars (that) Harvard academicians drive. I would interested to see a comparative evaluation (why : for the heck of it
) with cars driven by UC Berkeley and UChicago professors. It is obviously going to be hard to control other factors – weather, distance from suburbs, quality of public transport etc.
As an aside, as one might expect closing the comments section on his blog allows Mankiw Chacha slightly more leeway in choice of posts and tenor. This is an unusual Mankiw post.
~~~
Times of India was always injurious to intelligent beings or at least being in intelligent information seeking modes. Now they are also proven injurious to your computer.
Visitors to the IndiaTimes website are being bombarded by malware, some of which appear to target previously unknown vulnerabilities in Windows, a security researcher warns.
In all, the English-language Indian news site is directly or indirectly serving up at least 434 malicious files, many of which are not detected by antivirus software, according to Mary Landesman, a senior security researcher at ScanSafe. She said at least 18 different IP addresses are involved in the attack.
Visitors can be infected even if they have up-to-date systems and they don’t fall victim to tricks to install software or browser add-ons, she said. She urged people to avoid the site until it’s been cleaned up.
Join my Orkut TOI sucks community !
~~~
Read this post for the Game theoritic reasoning with respect to assassination. More specifically, why “Kasparaov should die”.
“Life’s like that” November 12, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in weird.add a comment
On a backside of some body lotion in a friend’s bathroom :
Directions : Apply all over the body.
When curiosity baffles. No idea what these products actually do.
Marriage Research November 11, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in contemplation, life.2 comments
Tyler links to Divya Mathur’s research on arranged marriages in India.
…when parents are involved in mate choice, sons are significantly less likely to marry college-educated women and women engaged in the labor force, after controlling for individual and family characteristics. I show that these effects are driven, at least in part, by parental preferences and cannot entirely be attributed to correlation between arranged marriages and unobserved characteristics.
Comments section of the above post is worth a read as well.
Why do parents have a say in any of this ? They should probably have a say if :
a) You are too young to know enough – but if you are old enough to marry, you are old enough to know whom to marry.
b) You want them to have a say (for whatever reasons)
c) The prospective spouses’ parents want your parents to approve of the alliance. Dubious at best, but believe me it happens. In-laws who demonstrate such preferences are unlikely to stop at that.
How can be make the already most complicated matching problem even more so but adding variables like the above ? I can’t think like a parent of a 20 something year old. (actually I can’t think like a parent at all). Its interesting if there is a website (like the PostSecret blog) where parents anonymously what actually prompted them to choose a particular bride/groom for their child and of course, the “just married” ones anonymously post about why they actually rejected all the proposals that came in and finally accepted the one they did.
My own nonsensical wishes apart, a systematic study of the topic was long overdue – even more creditable if that thesis is coming out of a prominent economics department and is being supervised by the likes of Gary Becker and Emily Oster.
Tricky bets November 10, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in CMU, ideas.4 comments
Somebody stole my idea again
.
In fact, some of his Yale colleagues are in the final stages of launching a business based on this very concept. They have started a company called stickK.com that will allow people to take out a contract on themselves. They pick a price. If they don’t lose a certain amount of weight, they lose the money, either to a charity, friends or family.
The ‘friends’, in my case is my CMU colleague Sanjika. I have a bet with him that if I don’t return to my pre-Jan 2006 levels by XX, I pay for his March 2008 trip to California (from Pittsburgh). The XX is something I choose really – I can say December so that tickets for March 08 will be cheap, but that gives me less time to lose weight. Or of course I can wait up to February before ‘giving up’ – that gives me more time to lose weight, but if I don’t, I pay a far more steep price on the airfare. And of course, if I do make it to my pre-Jan 2006 levels, Sanjika doesn’t give me nothing – after all I am already getting a healthier body !!
So the problem is not just of becoming healthier, but even deciding if and when I arrive at a point where I don’t think I can make it. I like problems like this – its so much like you deciding to get from place A to B the fastest. You see a shuttle bus arriving, but you know that there is a faster bus coming ’sometime’ in the next 15 minutes. Its a 10 minute journey. Should you wait for the next bus or take this one ? We faced this every now and then waiting to get to school back in 1991-92. An a few years ago going from from Mangalore to Suratkal.
Actually, I hate problems like that
Numbers in my life – Top 10 tags here and there edition November 8, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in blogging, numbers-in-my-life.1 comment so far
Another inconsequential, yet curiosity-quenching set of numbers to throw around.
Here are the top 10 tags for the posts on this blog
1. india
2. humor
3. America
4. life
5. economics
6. contemplation
7. rant
8. science
9. ideas
10. politics
Top 10 tags for my delicious bookmarks.
1. economics
2. india
3. politics
4. education
5. science
6. technology
7. history
8. psychology
9. culture
10. america
A measure, in some sense, of the difference between what I read and what I write. Or what I do and what I preach
And sorry DK for inflicting on you the tyranny of these numbers.
Previous tyrannies and inflictions.
Light November 4, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in blogging.1 comment so far
….(as in not heavy, not “not dark”)
Eeeks, 10 posts in the past 4 days, I will let you catch up
.
Rest of the week is going to be light.
Can blogs be objective vis-a-vis MSM ? November 4, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in blogging, media, politics.add a comment
Consider 2 bloggers X of left political persuasion and Y is from the right. For now lets focus not on social positions but on economic/trade related.
X regularly links to article such these from Paul Krugman :
Mr. Giuliani got his numbers from a recent article in City Journal, a publication of the conservative Manhattan Institute. The author gave no source for his numbers on five-year survival rates — the probability that someone diagnosed with prostate cancer would still be alive five years after the diagnosis. And they’re just wrong.
Y links to article B such as this from Greg Mankiw :
Our health care system is not perfect, but it has been a major source of advances in our standard of living, and it will be a large share of the economy we bequeath to our children. As we look at reform plans, we should be careful not to be fooled by statistics into thinking that the problems we face are worse than they really are.
For someone who is not really bothered with America’s healthcare problems, the summary is that Krugman thinks America’s healthcare is more screwed up than reported and Y thinks its less so.
Now both X and Y are not quantitative social scientists, to use a term broader than just ‘economists’ and as such are unable to independently and competently critique articles A and B, but they link to respective articles anyway.What do you do when you encounter Krugman’s article in X’s blog or Mankiw’s article in Y’s blog ?
In most cases, I just ignore it.
As a blogger, our defense would be that with other full-time jobs, family, community activities and errands to run, one seldom has time to come up with competent critiques of foreign subjects, so just outsource your thinking and put your faith in your favorite commentator – Krugman, Mankiw or Cowen, as the case may be. But even readers too have “full-time jobs, family, community activities and errands to run” and we don’t want to be saddled with the blogger’s long held positions and biases. Fair enough, ain’t it.
As a blogger I have no solution for this problem (other than to link to such stuff less frequently) and as a reader, I can afford to live with it I guess. But yeah, increasingly what kind of a blogger you are becomes more important than what you have to say on some issues – because your stand is predictable and credibility is at risk, even if your honesty/good intents are not in doubt.
Now note that both the articles I linked to appeared in the NYTimes within days of each other. So, mainstream media can at least make pretenses to objectivity (or some diversity in coverrage), but blogs with political content that are run by individuals or very small groups seldom should.
P.S: Closely related to “Political Philosophy as a consumer good.”
P.P.S : Just so I make it clear that I am not on some high horse, I am absolutely aware that the above discussion applies to this blog as well. If we meet up over coffee and you tell me that you ignore any content with an ideological hue when you read this blog, I will….I will just order another coffee.
“What do you believe is true though you cannot prove it ?” November 4, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in contemplation.add a comment
There is this really cool website called Edge.org. One of the many things they do is to ask over 100 odd experts and public thinkers from several fields one question each year and have their answers put up online. You can catch the series of questions here and clicking on each of those the answers as well.
One of the questions asked (2005) was “What do you believe is true though you cannot prove it ?”. Of course, my answers won’t really deserve to show up there anyway, but hey, I will answer anyway !
I think social networks are overrated.
I have lot of respect for and faith in the ability of experts to explain the past. Seldom in their ability to predict the future in matters such as these. We just don’t know.
What else explains things like sub-prime lending crisis – entirely man-made, partly wall-street made and they have some of the smartest brains, right ! What about the tech boom/bust at the turn of the century - all those entrepreneurs and venture capitalists hailed as superstars ?
Go back to read some of the magazine articles from 1999/2000 and am sure most of the guys making predictions were around then as well and often it looks like mistakes have not been lessons. Or maybe its whole new set of people doing the same mistakes. Today we make fun of how people (that often includes ourselves) evaluated companies from their market capitalization even if that number was 100 times the actual revenue. Now with facebook at $250 M in revenue and $15 B in evaluation (thats 60 times), its interesting to see where this goes. And each time you hear the same thing – “This time its different because blah…blah..blah.”.
A relevant link from Abi : A video
P.S: Somebody else concurs too.
That must-ache November 3, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in humor, reminisces-1990s.add a comment
From this weird website.
November (the month formally known as November) is a moustache growing charity event held during November each year. At the start of Movember guys register with a clean shaven face. The Movember participants known as Mo Bros then have the remainder of the month to grow and groom their moustache and along the way raise as much money and awareness about male health issues, in particular prostate cancer as possible. Movember culminates at the end of the month at the gala partés.
Should I take the bait ? After all, I recently told a friend that I don’t know anyone in the world who will look better with a mustache (women included). To get some insight, I looked up as usual this entry from my favorite encyclopedia.
Mustache is a contraction of must and ache; something that most probably hurts. This may be a reference to how a bad mustache hurts the eyes, or how much it may hurt to kiss someone with an uwieldy [sic] mustache, or how much it hurts to get stuff stick in one. The similarity in pronunciation to mistake is no coincidence: many mustaches result from mistakes. In fact, even if someone intentionally wears a mustache it is often considered a mistake.
I have not had a mush for a while. The last time I did was out of sheer paranoia. For an exam to be held in May 2000, I sent in a picture (for the hallticket) shown in Sep 1998. My looks had changed so much in the interim (mostly because I had no mush since mid 1999), that just a month before the exam I began to grow a mush to match my looks of the year before yester-year. I was successful – not in clearning the exam itself but in getting entry to the exam hall without any problems. This rates among the most paranoid I have been knowing that I was being paranoid.
Actually they must have had some evolutionary reasons to hang around so long. I just don’t know. As for my friend, she thought for a while and said -”No, what about Mammoty”. Okay, I leave that to a counterfactual historian.
(HT: Amit Verma.)
Reading Vs. Commenting November 3, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in blogging, contemplation.6 comments
Bloggers get feedback from readers – through page views/unique visitors the blogger gets an idea whether it is mattering that she/he is blogging at all, assuming of course that a blogger gainly some satisfaction/utility from being read (a fair assumption).
What about comments ?While comments reinforce this point every now and then, they are an incomplete and a not-so-comprehensive indicator of a blog’s popularity. Here are some possible reasons in the increasing order of political incorrectness.
- Comments require more effort and thought and are rather time-consuming – if people read blogs at work as a 5 minute diversion, they are unlikely to comment.
- There are other biases where some people comment only when they agree with your view and others only when they don’t. So there is an effect of the kind of readership you have rather than the absolute number.
- Some are hesitant to comment – much like public speaking fright, commenting online is not something everybody is willing to jump at.
- It might also be culture dependent. I was surprised to see that when a really popular Indian blogger opened up some of the posts for comments, there were far fewer than one might predict from the blog’s popularity. This may partly be due to the fact that different countries are at a different stage of adoption of blogging as a technology and a medium of influence.
- Not everyone is efficient and competent at putting their thoughts in writing – somehow they haven’t practiced writing for any other purpose other than when it was the only way out ! ( Note : this is different from not having a enormous vocabulary which is neither a necessary nor sufficient pre-requisite for writing well. Note also that this is different from not willing to comment as in point 3.)
In summary, while the absence of comments is not necessarily a bad thing, the presence is certainly good news for the blogger. (Not for everyone though)
Its kind of going to be tricky to request those readers who don’t comment to now comment to indicate whether there are reasons I have left out.
sort -n +increasing_political_incorrectness foo.txt > bar.txt November 3, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in contemplation, humor.1 comment so far
Today ( or if I last, today onwards ), everything I ever write/speak/list will be sorted in the order of increasing political incorrectness.
I think its a win-win – if you are reading through a list I wrote, you know exactly when to stop. If we are talking face to face, I know exactly when to stop.
For those of you who prefer it the other way around, just let me know in advance – we can also do sort -n -r +increasing_political_incorrectness foo.txt > bar.txt .
Mini-FAQ :
1. WTF is your title about ?
Delicious video November 3, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in videos.add a comment
I use Delicious, the social bookmarking website. As you are probably aware, the “Just been reading” section on this blog is infact directly linked from my delicious bookmarks.
My dad does too ! I did not use this video (“how to explain delicious to your parents”) but I agree it can be useful. (although I prefer if the narrator was not in that much of a hurry to get somewhere )
Like people you know (or are related to) independently in more than one way, so is Delicious to me – founded by a CMU grad and acquired by Yahoo! a few years ago.
Bookmarking on some centrally accessible location is indispensable really – I don’t remember the last time I said – “I saved it on my home computer. I will send you the link when I go home.”
Are you a better writer or a better ‘type-writer’ ? November 2, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in contemplation.10 comments
I was trying to write something today – write, not type and not fill a form which is a more structured activity, but write something as unstructured and impromptu as writing a letter. I realized how awful it had gotten over the years given that there has been little writing activity. Hardly taking notes during college and grad school, you lose that art of writing anything at all, without mistakes, misspelling, poor construction. Infact, don’t be surprised if this also takes a toll on your ability to ace exams where you have to write long answers ; it sure did to me, or so I am given to think. ( a good enough reason to take notes in class).
I don’t know at when in the last years I must have crossed the point where I had typed more characters than I ever wrote (I used to keep count, you know
). To be sure, its impossible to know if it ever did, but I imagine it must have. Also interesting – and I am sure this happened – is the point in life where your fastest typing speed just exceeded your best writing speed (for a given number of mistakes).
I still feel that I am a better writer with the keyboard than I ever was writing on paper. Its not just the obvious advantage of the backspace key but the ability to move entire sentences around which I often tend to do overdo. And once you move sentences around, you tend to (often justifiably) modify sentences themselves and this can often mean moving around sentences again
. But then one might argue that one sentence very well thought that went out on paper is better than several iterations of a sentence where the most frequently occurring ‘letter’ is the backspace.
Its hard to measure any of this however, even assuming you come up with a measure of what good writing really is. This is because there is an inherent bias in that most of my writing on paper was done a few years ago and arguably one might have improved writing skills over time by just having hung in there and written more. Ideally then you would need snapshots from around the same point in life where you wrote quite a bit and typed in as well. Fortunately for me, the time around 1997-2000 would qualify for such a study, except having to do any automatic analysis of paper-written material is rather cumbersome and time-consuming. And the nature of content is such that there is little scope to outsource the typing work.
Sorry about that silly, ungrammatical title – the best I could come up with. Maybe if I were writing this post, I would have come up with something ….well, whatever !
In the gulf November 2, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in geo-politics, rant.3 comments
Joy links to this article from the Times, a case of a French teenage boy raped by some natives and now the case getting complicated and in the process exposing (yet again !) the UAE authorities. The article has other gems such as “United Arab Emirates law does not recognize rape of males, only a crime called “forced homosexuality.”. The boy’s mother has started this website called – boycottdubai – where she says :
To all the Pakistani, Filipino, and Indian mothers who were expelled from Dubai to their countries of origin with their little children, wounded in their hearts, flesh and minds. This web site is open to all the mothers of the world united in the same Combat.
You know, there is such a thing called “resource curse” - and nowhere in the world is this more evident than the hell hole called ‘middle-east’ ( at least much of it !)
In many “ordinary” societies that are not resource-dependent, governments tax citizens, who demand efficient and responsive government in return. This bargain establishes a political relationship between rulers and subjects. In countries whose economies are dominated by natural resources, however, rulers don’t need to tax their citizens because they have a guaranteed source of income from natural resources. So this relationship between rulers and subjects breaks down. More insidiously, those benefiting from mineral resource wealth may perceive an effective and watchful civil service and civil society as a threat to the benefits that they enjoy, and they may take steps to thwart them. As a result, citizens are often poorly served by their rulers, and if the citizens complain, money from the natural resources enables governments to pay for armed forces to keep the citizens in check. Countries whose economies are dominated by resource extraction industries tend to be more repressive, corrupt and badly-managed.
Am sure there are many amongst us who will rise to defend things that happen there – judicial/legal systems, treatment of expatriates, other religious denominations and simply basic human rights. These are usually (and rightly) the favorite causes of the left and is it not then ironic that its the Indian left (or even the left in general – smart and mostly well intentioned – individuals not including politicians) that finds common cause with the rogues out there (while their children study in the Harvards and Oxbridges of the world). (my previous post explains this).
I actually feel bad for the many millions of Indians – mostly from Kerala/Karnataka – who have to go there to work because they are unable to find sufficiently remunerative options in India and who would otherwise not consider that an option. From an earlier NYTimes article -
Plagued by chronic unemployment, more Keralites than ever work abroad, often at sun-scorched jobs in the Persian Gulf that pay about $1 an hour and keep them from their families for years. The cash flowing home now helps support nearly one Kerala resident in three. That has some local scholars rewriting the Kerala story: far from escaping capitalism, they say, this celebrated corner of the developing world is painfully dependent on it.
“Remittances from global capitalism are carrying the whole Kerala economy,” said S. Irudaya Rajan, a demographer at the Center for Development Studies, a local research group. “There would have been starvation deaths in Kerala if there had been no migration. The Kerala model is good to read about but not practically applicable to any part of the world, including Kerala.”
Actually but for the global economy powered by fossil fuels, most countries would rather let them just be – have an economic embargo and sit put ! (Tom Friedman gets it right once a while.). Geographical isolation (in place of Australia perhaps) would be an added bonus.
If this post was too much to take, you can perhaps stay on the topic but read something with a much lighter tone.
Political philosophy as a consumer good November 1, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in ideas, intellectual.1 comment so far
Megan Mcardle hits the proverbial nail on the not so proverbial head when she says :
For most people, a lot of their beliefs are consumption goods. The irrational clustering of political beliefs–there is no logical reason that one’s views on abortion should be so tightly correlated with one’s view on business regulation or nationalized health care–indicate that there is a very strong social component to the formation of allegedly principled beliefs. The anger with which opposing views are met, and the in-group/out-group social dynamic of most political debate, suggest that for most of us, fitting in with our friends and feeling good about ourselves are at least as strong a component of belief formation as careful reasoning from first principles.
Think about it – once you figure out your position (lets ignore for now where that came from) on some of those key issues that you are really really passionate about, every position on every other issue just falls in place. It pretty much mirrors the view of that big group you identify with or that which opposes the view of the group you loathe for having divergent views on your core concerns.
What else explains the fundamental connection between being skeptical about global warming and opposition to gun control – both of which issues dear to the conservative right. Or for that matter, the connect between the support of Darwinian theory and opposition to spontaneous order in other spheres such as that of economic activity ?
Sum Fun November 1, 2007
Posted by Sharath Rao in humor, image.1 comment so far
Funniest organization : PETSA – People for Ethical Treatment of Stuffed Animals
PETSA focuses its attention on the four areas in which the largest numbers of stuffed animals suffer more: in damp and/or moldy closets and attics, in over-lighted collectors’ cases, in the hands of sadistic stuffed-toy bullies, and as dress-up guests at little girls’ tea parties. In addition, we work on various other issues, including the cruel use of washing machines not set on gentle cycle and the abuse inflicted on stuffed animals by backyard dogs.
Here is an example of things that will probably freak out PETSAians.
Disclaimer : I am a vegetarian (to the extent that egg is a vegetable), though that does not mean I eat stuffed plants (or stuffed eggs for that matter)
~~~
This site rocks man !! Absolutely for geeks. And here is for cat lovers. And here is for geeky cat lovers.